It has been some time since I posted good stories by pupils. With the examinations coming up and to make up for my tardiness, I'll be posting more such stories in the coming couple of weeks. I know, then the posts should not be entitled A Composition A Week, but never mind. :)
The constraints of Continuous Writing in the PSLE are rather limiting. The pupils are not encouraged to write about the supernatural, aliens or fantasy (which includes a range of characters from witches to elves to talking animals). In fact, some teachers have warned pupils that they would fail if they write about such topics in the examination.
Wow, think about that. It means that works like the Harry Potter series, the Lord of the Ring trilogy and the Narnia series, all considered classics in their own right, would have failed in the PSLE.
 |
You three would not have passed muster in Singapore's PSLE! |
That said, rules and regulation are rules and regulations so we teachers and tutors dutifully exhort our charges not to write about the abovementioned topics in all the-important PSLE, not even for the less important but still important school examinations.
But you know what? Children like such stories. They are so whimsical and amazing that children find them interesting and it is easy for them to immerse themselves in the worlds of such stories. And when given such topics to write about, the more natural writers simply get fired up and when they may be sometimes stuck for words, now they find a torrent pouring out.
Hence at times, to spark the pupils' interest, and to give them free rein to truly explore their creativity, in our classes, the tutors turn a blind eye and let the pupils write about these forbidden topics 'just this once'.
We have below an excellent example of such a story. Read and enjoy. We will share with you our analysis and why we think it is a great piece of work.
The assignment given was the beginning of the story below and the writer has to continue the story:
One night, after a movie, you were going
home. When you reached your home, you saw something strange outside your
neighbour’s house.
This was what the writer came up with:
[Warning: The story is more than 1000 words long.]
A REMARKABLE RAT
Dark rain clouds covered the night
sky as I reluctantly slung my bag over my shoulder and headed home. I had just
finished watching a movie with my best friend at the cinema and I was trudging
home, a wave of guilt flooding over me. I knew it was wrong not to revise for
the test for the next day but if I did not agree to go out with my friend, she
might just think that I was not keen to be her friend and our friendship would
just fade away. All because of the new girl, Cindy. Cindy wore black-rimmed
spectacles and she always topped the class – except for English. My best
friend, Hilary, had taken a liking to her and now she stuck to Cindy most of
the time because Cindy was intelligent. The next day would be our English test.
A really difficult one, the teacher had said in class. I groaned. I guess I had
to burn the midnight oil this time because if I did badly again, Hilary might
decide she did not want to be my friend anymore.
Glumly turning a corner, I was
shocked to espy a livid-looking man, my neighbour Mr Tan, about to strike a
helpless rat with the handle of a broom. The rat cowered below him, shaking
with fear. As I approach it, the rat turned its head to stare right at me. To
my astonishment, I heard it speak, ‘Please, rescue me! I promise I will be your
loyal friend forever!’